Charlotte, N.C., Apr 1, 2016 / 05:01 pm (CNA/EWTN News).- The overturn of a Charlotte, North Carolina ordinance allowing biological males to enter women’s restrooms helps offer important protections against sexual predators, said family advocacy groups this week.
“The (original) Charlotte ordinance jeopardized the safety of women, and children,” Tami L. Fitzgerald executive director of the North Carolina Values Coalition, told CNA March 29. “It would have allowed any man in any woman’s bathroom, locker or shower room at any time where women and young girls would be in various stages of undress and be exposed or exposed to. The governor and state legislature were right to intervene and block it.”
Fitzgerald was responding to the passage of House Bill 2 by the North Carolina General Assembly on March 23, which blocked a Charlotte City Council Ordinance that would have gone into effect on April 1.
The nondiscrimination ordinance involved housing, employment and public facilities. It would have allowed individuals to use bathrooms, locker rooms and shower facilities that corresponded with their self-perceived “gender identity,” even if this differs from their biological sex.
Fitzgerald cautioned that the ordinance could have been used by sexual predators as a license to harm women and children.
The ordinance was met with widespread opposition. In North Carolina, 69 percent were in favor of repealing the Charlotte ordinance, according to a poll by Survey USA, sponsored by the Civitas Institute.
In response, House Bill 2, also known as the Public Facilities Privacy and Security Act, was signed into law by Gov. Pat McCrory after a decisive vote in favor, with the House 83-25 and the Senate 32-0.
The law blocks the Charlotte ordinance and explicitly clarifies that individuals are to use public locker rooms and restrooms corresponding to their biological sex, as designated on their birth certificate.
“Even 12 Democrats crossed over to help pass the bill,” noted Fitzgerald. “This is not a partisan issue but a commonsense issue. You just don’t allow men in women’s bathrooms.”
John Rustin, president of the North Carolina Family Policy Council, told CNA March 30 that the Charlotte ordinance would have put the religious freedom of business owners at risk.
“The Charlotte ordinance is the type of measure that has been used in cities across the nation to go after florists, bakers, photographers, bed and breakfast owners, and small business owners who refuse to comply with a radical definition of sexuality and gender identity,” Rustin said.
“These small business owners have been sued and vilified because they have refused to use their gifts and talents, whether it is to bake a cake, take pictures or what have you, and participate in a same-sex ceremony because it violates their religious beliefs about what marriage truly is – the union of one man and one woman.”
But the American Civil Liberties Union of North Carolina disagrees and filed a lawsuit March 28 against the state, claiming it discriminates against the LGBT community. According to the lawsuit, the bill violates the Equal Protection Clause and Title IX.
Kellie Fiedorek, legal counsel with Alliance Defending Freedom, said that the lawsuit is “completely meritless and contradicts the commonsense principle that men and women need to have privacy and safety when entering an intimate setting.”
“This is not a violation of the Equal Protection Clause because under North Carolina law, everyone is treated the same,” she told CNA.
“The law simply looks at biology as stated on a person’s birth certificate and is blind to any other characteristic,” she said. “This is the only sensible and enforceable policy that has worked for hundreds of years. And the law also offers accommodations for those with special circumstances.”
Fiedorek also said that Title IX does not require schools to open restrooms to members of the opposite sex. Rather, it “specifically allows schools to provide separate bathrooms, showers and locker rooms on campus on the basis of biological sex.”
“Since Title IX became law almost 44 years ago, federal courts have consistently ruled in favor of schools having the right to adopt these privacy policies,” she continued.
At a news conference on March 29, State Attorney General Roy Cooper sided with the ACLU and said House Bill 2 is “discriminatory” and will hurt North Carolina’s economy. He vowed to repeal it and “restore North Carolina’s national reputation.”
Since signing the bill into law, Governor McCrory has received numerous boycott threats from companies and franchises.
More than 90 business leaders – including those from Google Ventures, Starbucks, Bank of America, Wells Fargo and Accenture – have called for the repeal of the law, saying that it “sanctioned discrimination.”
Threats of boycotting the state have followed with San Francisco Mayor Edwin M. Lee issuing an order banning federal employees from traveling to North Carolina. The NBA also threatened to move the 2017All-Star Game out of Charlotte.
Indiana and Georgia also recently received boycott threats from major corporations, including Apple, Disney and the NFL, after trying to enact laws protecting religious freedom.
Ryan T. Anderson, the William E. Simon senior research fellow in American principles and public policy at The Heritage Foundation, warned that some businesses are unjustly trying to impose their values on society.
“Big business should not get to dictate what our laws are going to be,” Anderson said. “We are now seeing the emergence of what I call a ‘cultural cronyism,’ which is similar to crony capitalism, whereby big business colludes with big government to get its way. In this instance, big business is trying to get the government to impose its cultural values and its definition of sexuality.”
Anderson said that these broad anti-discrimination measures are being used by activists to expand upon their same-sex marriage victory at the Supreme Court.
“These anti-discrimination ordinances include sexual orientation and gender identity so that anyone who does not comply will be accused of discrimination. It is a way to eliminate dissent.”
While the Supreme Court has ruled in favor of same-sex civil marriage, Anderson stressed that “freedom is a two-way street” that should respect all people.
“People should be free to live how they want to live,” he said. “But that doesn’t mean that we should rush in and allow biological males to have unfettered access to women and children’s bathrooms or that we should be shutting down Catholic adoption agencies opposed to helping same-sex couples adopt a child, or penalize schools that won’t employ teachers who undermine their religious teachings.”
Noting that the majority of people in North Carolina had opposed the original Charlotte ordinance, Anderson said that “the battle with the American people has not been lost” and urged public officials to be brave in overcoming threats from big business.
“The American people are in favor of laws that protect their religious freedom and the safety of women and children in restrooms,” he said. “It is the elites that are not. Public officials will need courage not to be bullied into submission – whether it is by corporate elites, media elites or Hollywood elite – to enact policies that preserve the common good.”
Article Archive
Carolina controversy: bathroom bills raise questions of safety, privacy
Related Articles • More Articles
null / Credit: Peter Hermes Furian via ShutterstockACI Prensa Staff, Apr 19, 2024 / 15:00 pm (CNA).The pontifical foundation Aid to the Church in Need (ACN) on April 19 condemned the kidnapping and murder of a catechist in Burkina Faso, West Africa.In a news brief, ACN informed ACI Prensa, CNA's Spanish-language news partner, that catechist Edouard Yougbare was kidnapped on Thursday night by "terrorists, and his lifeless body was found near Zigni this morning."According to other local sources, along with Yougbare, who was a member of Saatenga parish in Fada Gourma, Burkina Faso, more people were kidnapped and murdered."We are heartbroken by the loss of Yougbare. He served his community faithfully and his death is a devastating blow for the people of Saatenga," lamented Spaniard María Lozano, press and public relations director of ACN International."Catechists in Burkina Faso are on the front lines, risking their lives for the good of their people. Just two months ago, ano...
Pope Francis addresses the faithful at his Wednesday general audience on March 27, 2024. / Credit: Vatican MediaVatican City, Apr 19, 2024 / 10:07 am (CNA).In the latest move in Pope Francis' reform of the Vatican judiciary, the pope issued a new motu proprio on Friday on the retirement age and benefits for cardinal judges and magistrates in the Vatican's court system.The April 19 motu proprio states that Vatican magistrates will retire at the end of the judicial year in which they turn 75 and cardinal judges at the age of 80, unless Pope Francis asks them to remain in office beyond the age limit.Magistrates and judges who wish to resign from office before the retirement age can only do so with the approval of the pope.The pope also has the prerogative to dismiss magistrates unable to fulfill their duties at any time. Upon the termination of their duties, magistrates will retain the rights to assistance and welfare provided to Vatican citizens and employees.The motu proprio, wh...
Archbishop Marek Jedraszewski of Krakow announced on April 14, 2024, the decision to begin the process of beatification and canonization of Helena Agnieszka Kmiec, a young lay missionary murdered in Bolivia in 2017. / Credit: The Helena Kmiec FoundationACI Prensa Staff, Apr 19, 2024 / 07:00 am (CNA).Archbishop Marek Jedraszewski of Krakow, Poland, announced the decision to begin the process of beatification and canonization of Helena Agnieszka Kmiec, a young lay missionary murdered in Bolivia in 2017.The prelate said that after the preliminary phase began in December 2022, he made the decision to officially open the process for Kmiec after having consulted the Polish Bishops' Conference and receiving the go-ahead from the Vatican's Dicastery for the Causes of Saints."With this edict I call on all those who have any document, letter, or information about the Servant of God, both positive and negative, to send them to the Metropolitan Curia of Krakow before June 30," the archbish...