Indianapolis, Ind., Jan 16, 2016 / 04:54 pm (CNA/EWTN News).- A proposed law in Indiana would replace the state’s Religious Freedom Restoration Act with language that its advocates say is clearer in protecting religious liberty and certain other rights.
The measure, Bill 66, omits the amendment Indiana Gov. Mike Pence added to the Indiana Religious Freedom Restoration Act last April after intense backlash from critics, who called it “anti-gay” and threatened to boycott the state.
The amended “fix” stated that the religious freedom law would not permit discrimination for services, housing or employment based on sex, religion, disability, sexual orientation and gender identity.
Bill 66 does not include this stipulation, which some proponents of religious freedom believed to undermine the law’s purpose, leaving them vulnerable to legal attacks.
Like the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, the proposed new law would require “strict scrutiny” as the appropriate level of judicial review for legal challenges involving religious freedom. As a result, courts would evaluate cases based on certain strict criteria: Government may not place a substantial burden on free exercise of religion unless there is a compelling state interest for doing so, and the least restrictive means are used.
In addition to religious freedom, the bill would also protect five other rights with a similar “strict scrutiny” standard of judicial review: the right to worship; the right to free exercise and conscience; the right to freedom of thought and speech; the right of assemblage and petition; and the right to bear arms.
Bill 66 was recently sent to the Senate Judiciary Committee for a hearing.
“This new bill has many positive aspects,” Glenn Tebbe, executive director of Indiana Catholic Conference told CNA. “It provides for strict scrutiny for government to have as a criteria when engaging in people’s rights. And in particular with religious freedom, it does so in a clear manner, tying it to Indiana’s Bill of Rights.”
“The bill also removes the ‘fix’ added to RFRA proposed last year,” he continued. “The amended law now in effect leaves a lot of unanswered questions which could potentially lead to unnecessary conflict between people and institutions.”
“This new law addresses this and should be beneficial in the long-run to preserve the religious freedom of all citizens,” Tebbe said.
But some argue that the state’s Religious Freedom Restoration Act already protects religious freedom, questioning whether there is a need to focus only on a handful of rights in the bill.
“Indiana already has an effective RFRA law that protects religious freedom,” Rick Garnett, law professor at Notre Dame University told CNA. “Unfortunately, it has been badly misrepresented.”
“This legislation takes a new way to approach these issues by requiring strict judicial scrutiny of a catalogue of rights for some and not others,” he said. “Unlike RFRA laws with an established judicial track record, we have less certainty on how this new law will work in practice.”
“What we would need to know is if there is evidence in Indiana that these other rights mentioned in this bill are vulnerable and not being respected,” Garnett added.
Sen. R. Michael Young (R-Indianapolis), who sponsored the legislation, said he wanted it to be clear and focused.
“Last year, people misunderstood RFRA and so it was important for me to write this new law and clarify things,” Young told CNA.
“The right to protest government is as important as the right to free speech and thought, the right to bear arms, and the right of freedom of conscience and freedom of religion,” he maintained.
“When it comes to our core rights, we should have the highest judicial standards—that is, strict scrutiny,” Young said. “But strict scrutiny doesn’t apply to all 37 Articles of the state’s Bill of Rights. Many of these don’t apply to personal rights but to group rights.”
LGBT groups have opposed the bill, saying it could be used to discriminate against them and derail their efforts to obtain new civil rights protections.
But Young reassures his critics that this will not be the case.
“This law will not be used to discriminate against anyone,” he said. “There is nothing in this bill that will allow anyone to discriminate against anyone for any reason.”
“All it will ensure is that the court will have a standard it will use to make decisions in all cases,” Young continued. “If the issue concerns religious freedom, the court will use strict scrutiny to resolve the issue.”
“This law does not favor one group of people over another,” he said. “It protects all people and fundamental rights in the same manner.”
Photo credit: Henryk Sadura via www.shutterstock.com.
Article Archive
Indiana bill seeks to clarify religious freedom protection
Related Articles • More Articles
A Sacred Heart of Jesus Parish procession honoring the patroness of Cuba on Sept. 7, 2023. / Credit: Sacred Heart of Jesus parish in Havana, CubaACI Prensa Staff, Mar 28, 2024 / 16:00 pm (CNA).The regime of President Miguel Díaz-Canel in Cuba has prohibited several Holy Week processions in different cities of the country, including the El Vedado area of Havana as well as in Bayamo, a town that was the scene of major protests earlier this month.Last week, ACI Prensa, CNA's Spanish-language news partner, reported on the prohibition of processions in the Diocese of the Most Holy Savior located in the Bayamo-Manzanillo area in the province of Granma, due to the regime's fear that new protests would break out. The prohibition has been extended to the capital, Havana, according to a Catholic priest.In a March 25 Facebook post, Father Lester Zayas, pastor of Sacred Heart of Jesus Parish in the El Vedado business district of Havana, reported that the day before he had been notifie...
The Catholic faithful gathered in the Cenacle in Jerusalem for the Mass of the Lord's Supper that the Franciscan friars celebrated on Holy Thursday, March 28, 2024. The Cenacle is at the center of strong tensions and disputes regarding ownership and rights of access and celebration. An ancient tradition places King David's tomb here and over the centuries Jews and Muslims have leveraged this to first expel the Franciscans and then to prevent Christian worship, which they deemed sacrilegious. / Credit: Marinella BandiniJerusalem, Mar 28, 2024 / 17:15 pm (CNA).On Holy Thursday, the doors of the Cenacle in Jerusalem were opened to welcome the Franciscans of the Custody of the Holy Land. In this "Upper Room," called the Cenacle in the Holy Land, Jesus had his Last Supper, washed his apostles' feet, and instituted the Eucharist. It was here that the Franciscans celebrated the Mass of the Lord's Supper, reenacting those same gestures. (At the Basilica of the Holy Sepulcher,...
The Oregon State Capitol in Salem. / Credit: Zack Frank/ShutterstockWashington, D.C. Newsroom, Mar 28, 2024 / 15:00 pm (CNA).The Oregon Health Authority (OHA) is reporting a significant rise in assisted suicide prescriptions and deaths in the state, a move that comes after authorities in 2022 began allowing out-of-state residents to access the lethal services.Since the state's passage of the "Death with Dignity Act" in 1997, assisted suicide numbers have been generally rising there, with a markedly sharp uptick since 2013. OHA on March 20 released its 2023 assisted suicide data summary that reported a considerable increase in suicide prescriptions in 2023. The study found that assisted suicide prescriptions in the state rose from 433 in 2022 to 560 last year.Of those 560 prescriptions, 367 people are known to have died from ingesting the suicide "medications." This is up from the 304 who died from assisted suicide drugs in Oregon in 2022.Over half, or 56%, of the assisted ...